
Some cities came back from the ash. Others never did — here's what decided which.
A volcanic eruption can erase a city from the map in an instant, or push its residents elsewhere over years of unrest. Some cities rebuilt on the same ground, saving a harbor or other critical infrastructure; others left their old sites as memorials and never went back. This list follows ten real cities touched by volcanic disaster, from Pompeii to Legazpi, tracing the different paths people chose after destruction.
How this list was built
- Only cities with documented eruption history and confirmed damage-and-recovery outcomes are included
- Ordered chronologically, from Pompeii in 79 CE to still-active Goma and Legazpi today
- Each entry is framed around three stages — evacuation, recovery, and remembrance — rather than death toll or eruption size
The same volcanic damage can lead to very different recoveries depending on land ownership, jobs, transportation, and whether a community could agree on a path forward. Read each entry through those three stages rather than just comparing death tolls or eruption size. Cities near volcanoes still active today can have exclusion zones and alert levels that shift quickly, so check the latest word from local observatories before visiting. Ranks 1-4 are cities preserved as ruins or memorials, 5-6 are cases where rebuilding itself was in question, and 7-10 are cities still living alongside an active volcano today.
How to compare these
If you want to start with a recovery success story, look at #5 Heimaey, which saved its harbor. If you're curious about cases where rebuilding itself was in doubt, read #3 Armero and #8 Chaitén side by side. To see how cities still coexist with active volcanoes today, compare #7 Goma with #10 Legazpi — the contrast in approach is stark.
When comparing entries, look past the scale of damage alone to how land ownership, jobs, and community agreement shaped each city's speed of recovery. This information reflects the time of research, and exclusion zones and alert levels shift frequently, so check the latest bulletins from local tourism authorities and volcano observatories before visiting.
Frequently asked questions
Can you actually visit these ruined cities today?
Some, like Pompeii and Saint-Pierre, are open as archaeological or historic sites. Others, like Plymouth and Armero, remain restricted zones or memorial grounds only. Check current access rules with local tourism authorities and volcano observatories before planning a visit.
Is it safe to visit cities near volcanoes that are still active?
Cities like Goma and Legazpi sit near volcanoes that remain active, and accessible areas shift with alert levels. Checking Smithsonian/USGS weekly reports or local observatory bulletins right up until your trip is the safest approach.
What separated the cities that recovered from the ones that didn't?
Places like Heimaey that managed to protect key infrastructure, like a harbor, recovered relatively fast. Chaitén, where the eruption rerouted the river itself, sparked years of debate over whether to rebuild at all. Beyond the scale of damage, land, jobs, and whether residents could agree mattered just as much.
Did any of these cities relocate entirely after the disaster?
Yes. #6 Rabaul's administrative functions shifted to nearby Kokopo after a 1994 eruption, and #8 Chaitén sparked years of debate over rebuilding in place versus relocating after its river was rerouted. Both cases show that deciding where to live again mattered as much as the rebuilding itself.
What order are the cities on this list arranged in?
They're ordered chronologically by eruption date, from Pompeii in 79 CE (#1) through Saint-Pierre in 1902, Armero in 1985, Plymouth and Shimabara in the 1990s, up to still-active Goma and Legazpi (#10). This isn't a ranking of activity level or danger, so check current alerts separately before any visit.
Get new lists before anyone else
Once a week — only the new lists worth your time.
No spam · unsubscribe in one click
